Skip to content

Free practice · 15–20 minutes

Argument clinic

Read two answers to the same fictional evidence. Find where an argument outruns its support, then write a narrower conclusion of your own.

This teaches reasoning from evidence; it states no UK legal rule and gives no university mark. Use your actual rubric for assessed work.

The evidence

A fictional campus cycle hub asks 12 volunteers about opening hours. Eleven favour longer hours. The hub has 820 registered users. The survey does not ask which hours people want. No staffing or cost information is supplied.

Compare the answers

What recommendation can these observations support?

Answer A

Eleven out of twelve users want longer hours, so the survey proves that almost all 820 users need the hub open all night. The university should introduce 24-hour opening immediately.

Answer B

Eleven respondents favour longer hours, which gives a reason to investigate unmet demand. A small volunteer sample does not establish what all registered users want, and longer hours does not necessarily mean overnight access. Ask when access is needed and examine staffing and cost before choosing whether to test a limited extension.

Illustrative checks

  • Represent the supplied observations accurately.
  • Explain the link from evidence to conclusion and its limits.
  • Address a relevant objection without inventing facts.

These are practice checks, not university marking criteria.

Your turn

Write first, then open each full rationale. More than one carefully justified answer may be defensible.

Read the answer and rationale

First, A generalises from 12 self-selected volunteers to all 820 users without evidence that the sample represents everyone. Second, a preference for unspecified longer hours becomes a need for all-night opening. The survey proves neither step.

Read the answer and rationale

B reports the observed count accurately, separates an indication of interest from a population estimate, and identifies what is missing. Its next step is provisional. B does not prove that extended hours will work or that they should be rejected.

Read the answer and rationale

A fair response acknowledges that cost and narrows the proposal: for example, ask a short follow-up question through an existing channel and estimate staffing needs first. That channel and its cost are possibilities, not facts provided by this exercise. Deferring the investigation could also be defensible if its cost is too high. Explain the trade-off.

A possible shape: observed result → limit → proportionate next step. Your view may differ if you explain its evidence.

Transfer to a new example

A fictional equipment desk recorded 18 reports about slow laptops and six about faulty chargers. It did not record the number of devices issued, severity, reporting method or repair cost.

Read the full answer and rationale

The counts alone do not establish comparative failure rates, impact or the value of replacing laptops. The desk could compare affected devices, severity and repair options before choosing a priority. A charger fault might have greater safety or access consequences, but that is a possibility to investigate, not a fact established here. A different provisional choice can be reasonable if its evidence and limits are clear.

Keep your practice notes

Your typed notes stay in this browser page for this visit. They are not sent to Durmah, automatically saved or attached to an account. Download a local text file before closing or refreshing the page.

Continue learning

Compare this reasoning exercise with the critical analysis film, which asks what a claim, objection and response each contribute. See the developing study path for more practice with sources and arguments.

Educational context: QAA Law Subject Benchmark Statement. This original fictional exercise does not represent an official marking task or QAA endorsement.

This guide is for general educational purposes only. It is not legal advice, and it does not guarantee any academic, admissions or career outcome. Expectations vary between universities, firms, chambers and years, so always check your own institution's guidance, each employer's published information, and your university careers service. Durmah is independent and is not affiliated with or endorsed by any university, regulator or employer.